Investing in a vacation home offers the same
basic tax benefits as owning your own home. It isn’t the deduction for
interest and taxes that makes it a tax shelter. The major tax benefit is the
value of the use of the property on a rent-free and tax-free basis. Instead
of using your money to earn taxable investment income, you are using it to
provide vacation facilities that would otherwise have to be paid for with
after-tax income.
The investment of $50,000 in a lakeside cabin
might be equivalent to an investment earning about $4,500 tax-free. If
it would cost $150 per night to rent comparable facilities, the vacation home
would have to be used at least 30 days per year to break even on the
investment. However, a vacation home can be rented for up to 15 days per
year, and the income will be tax-free. So, if you use the property only 15
days and rent it for another 15 days (at $150 per day), you would still
receive a “yield” equal to a tax-exempt bond.
In addition, you would be likely to realize
some substantial appreciation in the price of the vacation home over a period
of years, and any gain from the sale would likely qualify as a tax-favored,
long-term capital gain, at a maximum rate of 20%.
To the extent that a vacation home is
financed, the interest expenses are deductible in the same way as interest on
a primary residence. Any real estate taxes are also deductible if you itemize
your deductions. To the extent that you rent the vacation home for more than
15 days per year, the income and related expenses could be reported on
Schedule E and you could allocate a portion of the interest and taxes to that
schedule.
The tax law permits homeowners to sell their
principal residence without owing a capital gains tax for the first $250,000
of gain. ($500,000 for a married couple filing jointly.) The trouble with that
tax break is that you still need a place to live and you will end up using the
money to pay rent.
Consequently, the $250,000/$500,000 tax free
gain on selling your home is a mixed tax benefit.
But ... there is a way to get the
full benefit of that tax break and to also end up with a residence without a
mortgage, when you retire. Use some of your investment funds to buy a second
home that will be adequate for your needs when you are ready to retire.
Buy the home in a location where
you want to live after you retire. That could be in the same town where
you live now, at the seaside, on a lake or in the mountains. Make sure
the home is also in an area where it will be easy to keep it rented most of
the time, with good quality tenants.
If you don’t want to manage the property
yourself (or if it’s located out of town) locate a reliable real estate
management company or find someone you can rely on to take care of the
property for you - for a fee, or for a part of the rental income. Buy the
home with a mortgage if you need to, but be sure that you will be able to make
use of any tax deductions and that you can afford to handle the debt payment
obligations if the property isn’t always rented. Then, the tenants will help
you to make the mortgage payments.
In about 15 to 25 years you will have a second
home that is all yours, with no mortgage.
When you sell your current residence and make
the election to take up to $250,000/$500,000 of gain tax free, you can move to
your second home and use the exempt income to increase your retirement
income.
CAPITAL GAINS
If you own some rental property, you can
convert the rental property into residential property without having to pay
taxes on the property. If your rental property isn’t the kind you want to live
in, you can do a tax free
exchange of the rental property before you convert it to residential
property.
With some careful planning, you could swap a
small office building for some rental residential property and later convert
that property into a retirement residence.
INCOME SHIFTING
Some parents I know had two or more children
who attended the same university. These parents bought a small rental property
near the university, in which the children lived. After the last child
graduated, the house was sold. (It could also have been kept as an
investment.) Letting your dependents occupy a home without rent is not a
taxable gift. Of course, this tactic might not appeal to you if your children
are strongly motivated to join a fraternity/sorority or to live in a college
dorm.
ESTATE AND GIFT TAXES
If you do buy a residence for your college age
children to live in, no gift is involved unless you buy the residence in the
name of your children.
If you have owned your home for more than ten
years, it’s probably worth a lot more than you paid for it. When you die,
that untaxed gain remains untaxed. The house is re-valued at the current
market value at the date of death. Any unpaid mortgage loans are paid and
deducted from the estate proceeds. In the case of a jointly owned home, it’s
almost treated as if there were two properties. One half is re-valued as
described above. The other half retains the tax cost that it had. Thus, if a
jointly owned home cost $50,000 (including improvements) and was worth
$200,000 when you died, it would have a new tax cost of $125,000 for your
surviving spouse. That’s 50% of the $200,000 value at the date of death, plus
50% of the $50,000 cost.
The $250,000/$500,000 tax free gain is wasted
in the sense that the tax free gain and a step up in basis isn’t available on
the same residence. In order to get the benefit of both, one residence must
be sold to realize the gain and a second residence must be purchased or
obtained from the conversion of rental property to personal use. Then the
second home can get a step up in basis at the time of death. When a home is
kept by a surviving spouse, part of the potential tax free gain is reduced by
the re-valuation described above. If a home is gifted, the gift tax value is
based on the market value, but the tax basis to the donee is the same as the
basis to the donor. If any debt on the home exceeds the fair market value of
the home and the property is transferred by gift, subject to the debt, then
the donor will have taxable income to the extent of any debt in excess of the
value of the property.
Related Articles and Links